When Should You Pick Up the Phone Instead of Sending the Email?
Quick Answer
When should you pick up the phone instead of sending the email? An agency COO on what belongs in writing, what belongs on a call, and why it protects deals.
When Should You Pick Up the Phone Instead of Sending the Email?
Most deals that stall over email were never really stuck on the terms. They were stuck on a sentence somebody read the wrong way, followed by a reply written in self-defense, followed by two more people copied in for moral support. By the fourth message, the thread is about the thread.
A big part of my job as COO is contracts and negotiation: statements of work, master service agreements, mutual NDAs, talent fee questions and vendor onboarding with large holding companies. Email is essential to all of it, and it's also where a perfectly good deal can go to get misunderstood. In this article, I share how I decide when a conversation belongs on the phone instead of in the inbox.
Quick answer: Pick up the phone when positions differ, money or scope is in question, emotions are running high, or an email thread has stopped moving. Keep facts, dates and agreed terms in writing. Ian Drummond, COO of Hollywood Branded, recommends keeping sensitive emails short, taking the substance to a call, and sending a written recap afterward.
Email Is Where Tone Goes to Get Misread
You read your own message with your voice in your head, so the warmth and the nuance feel obvious. The person on the other end reads it with their own mood, their own deadline and their own boss looking over their shoulder. Anyone who has spent time in a principal's office knows the parent email that starts calm and ends with three administrators copied, and business email works the same way, with more legal departments.
There's solid research on how big that gap is. In experiments published in 2005, psychologists Justin Kruger and Nicholas Epley asked people to send messages meant to be sarcastic or serious. Senders predicted about 78% of recipients would read the tone correctly. Listeners who heard a voice recording got it right about 75% of the time, but people reading the same words in email got it right only 56% of the time, barely better than a coin flip, while believing they were right 90% of the time. Everyone was confident, and almost half were wrong.
In a negotiation, that gap is expensive. A line you meant as flexible reads as a refusal. A quick reply reads as dismissive, and a careful, detailed reply reads as a lawyer warming up. Each misread adds a day, a defensive response and another person on the thread, and none of it has anything to do with the deal itself.
What Belongs in Writing?
Writing is for the record. Facts, dates, deliverables, approvals, agreed terms and the final version of anything that will be signed belong in writing, and the contract itself is the most important writing of all. If something matters later, it needs to exist somewhere both sides can point to.
Writing is also the right place for the simple stuff: confirming a meeting, sending a document, answering a direct question with a direct answer. Not every exchange needs a call, and nobody wants to be on the receiving end of a meeting that should have been two sentences.
The trick is keeping sensitive emails short. When something is tense or complicated, the written version should name the issue and suggest a time to talk. Trying to win the argument in paragraphs mostly produces longer paragraphs in reply.
When Does a Conversation Need to Move to a Call?
My working rule has a few triggers. If the two sides want different things on money, scope, rights or timing, that's a call. If someone is frustrated, that's a call. If a thread has gone back and forth three times without moving, it's definitely a call, because the fourth email won't be the one that fixes it.
A call lets you hear the actual concern underneath the stated position. Sometimes the redline that looks like a hard no is really a procurement requirement, a budget cycle or a person who needs to show their boss they pushed back. You can learn that in two minutes on the phone and spend two weeks not learning it over email.
It's the same reason coaches don't fix a back line with a note taped to the locker room door. Some corrections need a voice, a little context and a chance for the other person to ask a question. The email that sets up the call can be four sentences: thanks for the response, a couple of points are worth talking through live, two time options, and a promise to send a recap afterward. Firm, friendly and easy to say yes to.
Why Does This Matter for Brand Partnerships?
Brand partnerships usually involve more than two parties. A single deal can include a brand, its agency, a studio or network, talent representatives and a holding company's procurement team, each with its own priorities and its own legal reviewer. The more people on a thread, the more ways a sentence can be read.
At Hollywood Branded, partnerships are built on Mutual Benefit, which means the brand and the partner both have to come out ahead. You can't get there if every exchange feels like a standoff. Taking the hard parts to a call protects the relationship, and the relationship is often worth more than the deal in front of you, because the same studio, network or rep will be across the table again next year.
This is also a big part of what brands get when they work with an agency. Somebody on your side who knows which conversations to have live and which ones to put in writing can keep a partnership moving when it would otherwise stall.
The Recap Is the Part Everyone Skips
A call without a recap is just a nice conversation. Within the same day, send a short written summary of what was agreed, what is still open and who owns the next step. That email turns the call into the record, and it gives the other side a chance to correct anything you heard differently.
Next time you're about to send a long email into a tense thread, stop. Send the four-sentence version instead, make the call, and put the outcome in writing. You'll close faster, and you'll still be on good terms when it's done.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Is it better to negotiate by phone or email?
A. Use both, for different jobs. Phone or video calls are better for working through disagreements on money, scope or timing because tone is easier to read and real concerns surface faster. Email is better for documenting facts, terms and what was agreed.
Q. Why is tone so often misread in email?
A. Writers hear their own intended tone when they reread a message, but readers bring their own context and mood. In Kruger and Epley's 2005 research, email recipients identified sarcasm or seriousness correctly only 56% of the time, even though senders expected about 78% accuracy.
Q. What should you do after a negotiation call?
A. Send a short written recap the same day that lists what was agreed, what is still open, and who owns each next step. The recap creates a shared record and gives the other party a chance to correct any misunderstanding before it reaches the contract.
Eager To Learn More?
Here are a few more reads on partners, relationships and doing deals well:
- Why Your Agency Partner Choice Defines Your Success
- What Does Authentic Mean to Your Brand Partner
- What Brands Really Owe the People They Put in the Spotlight
Want to stay in the know with all things pop culture? Look no further than our Hot in Hollywood newsletter! Each week, we compile a list of the most talked-about moments in the entertainment industry, all for you to enjoy!

