Commission or Retainer: How Should a Brand Partnership Agency Get Paid?

Quick Answer

 

Commission or retainer: how should a brand partnership agency get paid? A COO explains common agency fee models, tradeoffs and what to ask about costs.

Commission or Retainer: How Should a Brand Partnership Agency Get Paid?

The fee section is often the shortest part of an SOW and the part that gets read most carefully, usually twice and usually by procurement. It used to be even shorter. For roughly a century, advertising agencies got paid the same way: 15% of the media they bought. Researchers Sharon Horsky and Robert Zeithammer traced how that model held from the late 1800s into the 1980s before it finally broke apart, and according to UCLA Anderson Review, billings-based agency compensation fell from 61% of advertisers in 1994 to 10% in 2003. The industry has been arguing about the replacement ever since.

Budget season is here, and brands planning entertainment and partnership work for next year are asking a fair question about how the agency should get paid. I spend a lot of my time on SOWs and MSAs, so I see how much a fee structure shapes the work that follows. In this article, I break down the common ways brand partnership agencies get paid, the tradeoffs of each and what brands should ask.

Quick answer: Brand partnership agencies are usually paid by retainer, project fee, commission on a deal or spend, performance incentives or a hybrid of these. No single model is best. The right structure matches the scope of work, and brands should always ask the agency to separate its own fees from third-party costs like talent, licensing, production and usage rights.


The Menu, Explained Plainly

Most agency fee structures fall into a handful of models. A retainer is a recurring fee for an agreed scope of ongoing work, such as strategy, relationship management and a steady flow of opportunities. A project fee is a fixed price for a defined piece of work, like a single campaign or event. A commission is a percentage of something, whether that's media spend, creator fees or the value of a deal. Performance incentives add a bonus tied to agreed results, and a hybrid combines a base fee with one of the others. Each one is a tool built for a different job.

Fees have clearly won the bigger argument. The ANA's 2022 Trends in Agency Compensation study found that 82% of marketers use fees in at least one agency agreement, while performance incentives dropped to 41% from 61% in 2013. In influencer work specifically, the ANA's newer research, summarized by Marketing Dive, found agency pay split 55% project-based and 45% retainer-based, with 25% tying pay to KPIs.


What Are the Tradeoffs of Commission vs. Retainer?

Think about how a Premier League club pays for a player. There's the transfer fee, paid once to land the signing, and there are wages, paid every week to keep that player performing. Commission works a lot like a transfer fee. It rewards closing a specific deal and lines up neatly with a single outcome, but it can nudge an agency toward bigger deals instead of better-fitting ones, and it pays little for the strategy and relationship work that happens before anything closes.

A retainer works more like wages. It funds the ongoing work that makes good deals possible: research, outreach, relationship building, negotiation and the many conversations that never become a press release. The risk is drift. If the scope isn't written clearly, a retainer can turn into "we're paying, so do everything," which helps no one.

Project fees sit in between and work well for first-time engagements or one-off moments. Performance incentives sound attractive, but they only work when both sides agree on what can be measured fairly and what the agency actually controls. Whatever the model, the useful test is whether it pays for the work you actually need, and the cheapest option on paper rarely passes it.


The Line Item That Causes the Most Confusion

In entertainment and brand partnerships, the agency's fee is rarely the only cost. Talent fees, licensing royalties, production costs, usage rights, creator fees, union or guild obligations, travel and media can all sit on top. Those are third-party costs, and they belong to someone else.

When those costs get bundled with the agency's fee, brands lose visibility. The same ANA influencer research found that only 51% of marketers have full visibility into what creators are actually paid. That's a contracting problem, not a creative one.

At Hollywood Branded, our practice is to keep agency fees and third-party costs on separate lines, so a brand can see exactly what it's paying for strategy and execution versus what goes to a partner, a creator or a rights holder. It makes conversations easier for everyone, including the partners, because Mutual Benefit is hard to build on numbers nobody can see.


What Should Brands Ask an Agency About Fees?

Before you sign, ask the agency to walk you through a few things in plain language:

  • What exactly the fee covers, and what's out of scope.
  • Which costs are passed through, and whether any are marked up.
  • Who holds the contract with talent, creators or licensors.
  • What happens to the fee if a deal doesn't close.
  • Which usage rights are included, for how long and in which territories.

Also ask what the agency does between deals. A lot of value in this business happens before anything is signed. When Hollywood Branded negotiated Expensify's partnership with the F1 film, the result was more than 600 million impressions, and much of the work that made it possible happened in strategy, access and negotiation long before the film opened. A fee structure should recognize that work instead of pretending it's free.

A good agency will welcome these questions. A great one will answer them before you ask.


Put the Fee Conversation in the First Meeting

If you're planning partnership work for 2027, don't wait until the proposal arrives to talk about how the agency gets paid. Bring it up in the first serious conversation, describe the work you actually need and ask which structure the agency would recommend for that scope and why.

Then put the answer in the SOW, clearly, with the fees and the third-party costs on their own lines. The paperwork is where a good partnership starts.

New call-to-action


Frequently Asked Questions

Q. How do brand partnership agencies typically charge?

A. Brand partnership agencies typically charge through retainers for ongoing work, project fees for defined campaigns, commissions on deal value or spend, performance incentives or a hybrid. Fee-based models dominate across marketing, with an ANA study finding 82% of marketers use fees in at least one agency agreement.


Q. Is a retainer or commission better for an entertainment marketing agency?

A. It depends on the work. A retainer suits ongoing strategy, relationship building and a steady pipeline of opportunities, while a commission or project fee can suit a single defined deal. Many brands use a hybrid. The key is that the structure matches the scope and that scope is written clearly in the agreement.


Q. What third-party costs come with brand partnerships?

A. Common third-party costs include talent and creator fees, licensing royalties, production costs, usage rights, union or guild obligations, travel and paid media. These are separate from the agency's own fee, and brands should ask for them to be listed on separate lines so they can see where every dollar goes.


Eager To Learn More?

More reads on choosing and working with the right partners.

Want to stay in the know with all things pop culture? Look no further than our Hot in Hollywood newsletter! Each week, we compile a list of the most talked-about moments in the entertainment industry, all for you to enjoy!

New call-to-action

 

Table Of Contents

    WHAT'S HOT IN HOLLYWOOD

    Want to keep your pulse on what Hollywood has to offer? Sign up below to get on our HOT IN HOLLYWOOD partnership updates!