What Should a Founder Look for in a COO?
Quick Answer
What should a founder look for in a COO? A COO at a founder-led agency explains the traits that matter: complement, judgment, ownership and the right to say no.
What Should a Founder Look for in a COO?
Ask ten founders what a COO does and you'll get ten answers, and most of them will start with "everything I don't want to do." That's closer to right than it sounds. There's no standard version of the role, which makes it very easy to hire for the title without deciding which job actually needs doing.
I work alongside Stacy Jones, who founded Hollywood Branded in 2007 and still leads it as CEO. Founder-led companies have a particular rhythm, and the COO's job is to make that rhythm sustainable as the business grows. As founders sit down to plan 2027, plenty of them are asking whether it's time to add one. In this article, I explain what a founder should look for in a COO, and what a COO should take off a founder's plate.
Quick answer: A founder should look for a COO who complements their strengths, owns operations such as contracts, finance, hiring and systems, and makes sound decisions without escalating everything. The right COO turns the founder's vision into repeatable processes, which frees the founder to focus on strategy, relationships and growth.
Start by Deciding Which Job You Need Done
Before a founder writes a posting, they should decide what problem the hire solves. Nate Bennett and Stephen Miles made that point twenty years ago in a Harvard Business Review article titled "Second in Command: The Misunderstood Role of the Chief Operating Officer," where they found there's no single COO job and identified seven different reasons companies hire one, from carrying out the CEO's strategy to mentoring a new CEO to complementing the CEO's strengths. Some companies need someone to carry out a strategy that's already set. Some need a partner. Some need someone to lead a specific initiative, like a turnaround or a major expansion. Each of those calls for a different person.
The most common fit in a founder-led business is the complement. The founder is usually the vision, the face and the source of the company's best ideas and relationships. The COO should be strong exactly where the founder doesn't want to spend time, whether that's contract terms, vendor onboarding, financial reporting or the hiring process. Very few founders lie awake wishing they could spend more time on indemnification clauses, and a good COO is the person who doesn't mind them.
Hire for the gap you actually have.
What Should a COO Take Off a Founder's Plate?
At Hollywood Branded, my work covers operations, contracts and negotiation, finance, HR and hiring, business development support and AI adoption. That means statements of work, master service agreements, NDAs, vendor setup with large holding companies, applicant assessments and the AI workflows our team uses every day. None of it is glamorous, and all of it has to be right.
The test for any of these areas is simple: if the founder is still the bottleneck on it, it belongs to the COO. A founder who personally reviews every contract redline and every job description is spending hours on work that someone else can own completely.
The goal is to give the founder back time for what only the founder can do. In a pop culture agency, that's the vision, the relationships and the ideas that make brands want to work with you.
How Do You Know a COO Candidate Has Real Judgment?
A COO who brings every decision back to the founder is really a very expensive inbox. The right candidate makes calls inside clear boundaries, explains the reasoning afterward and escalates only what truly needs the founder.
I'm in the middle of redesigning how Hollywood Branded assesses applicants, so I think about this question more than is probably healthy. Look for evidence in how candidates talk about past work. Ask them to describe a decision they made without approval and how they communicated it. Ask about a time they disagreed with a leader and what happened next. The details in those answers reveal more than any resume.
Co-teaching is the closest comparison I know. Two teachers sharing a classroom only works when each one can run the room alone and both trust the other's call. If one teacher has to check with the other before answering a student's question, the class stalls.
What This Means for Founder-Led Businesses
The biggest value a COO brings is turning what the founder knows into systems the whole team can run. Founders often carry the company's playbook in their heads, which works fine until the founder is on a plane. A good COO writes it down, builds the process around it and assigns an owner to every step.
At Hollywood Branded, that system has a name. Our pathway runs Playbook → Radar → Unlock Access → Produce → Amplify → Grow, and it's how brands move from strategy to a lasting place in pop culture. My job is to make sure each step has the contracts, budgets, people and tools it needs, so the team can run it reliably and the founder can focus on where it goes next.
That's also why the right COO has to be willing to say no. Saying no to a scope that doesn't fit, a vendor term that doesn't work or a hire that isn't right protects the business the founder built. A COO who only says yes isn't doing the job.
Write the Job Before You Write the Posting
If you're a founder thinking about a COO for 2027, start with a list of every recurring decision that currently waits on you. Circle the ones you'd gladly never touch again. That list is the real job description, and it will tell you whether you need an operator, a partner or a specialist.
If you're also thinking about how outside partners can carry some of that load on the marketing and brand partnership side, Hollywood Branded is happy to talk through what that could look like.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. When should a founder hire a COO?
A. A founder should consider a COO when operational decisions such as contracts, finance, hiring and vendor management are regularly waiting on the founder and slowing the business. The clearest signal is that the founder is spending more time on operations than on vision, clients and growth.
Q. What does a COO do in a small company?
A. In a small company, a COO typically owns the operational side of the business, including contracts, finance, HR and hiring, vendor relationships and internal systems. The role turns the founder's vision into repeatable processes so the company can grow without every decision running through one person.
Q. What are the different types of COO roles?
A. A 2006 Harvard Business Review article by Nate Bennett and Stephen Miles identified seven reasons companies hire a COO, including implementing the CEO's strategy, leading a specific initiative, mentoring a new CEO, complementing the CEO's strengths and serving as a partner to the CEO. Founders should decide which role they need before hiring.
Eager To Learn More?
Here are a few more reads on building a business and choosing the right partners:
- Why Your Agency Partner Choice Defines Your Success
- Why Does Creative Strategy Matter More Than Marketing Metrics?
- Why Does Product Placement Build Brand Equity That Lasts?
Want to stay in the know with all things pop culture? Look no further than our Hot in Hollywood newsletter! Each week, we compile a list of the most talked-about moments in the entertainment industry, all for you to enjoy!

