Why Did We Make AI Mandatory in Our Hiring Assessment?
Quick Answer
Why make AI mandatory in a hiring assessment? Hollywood Branded COO Ian Drummond explains why the test is judgment in guiding AI, not prompt tricks.
Why Did We Make AI Mandatory in Our Hiring Assessment?
I proctored a lot of tests in 22 years of teaching English, and the rule never changed: put it away, eyes on your own paper. Plenty of hiring processes still apply that rule to AI, treating it like a calculator on a math final. That's an odd stance when two-thirds of business leaders say they wouldn't hire someone without AI skills, according to the 2024 Work Trend Index from Microsoft and LinkedIn, a survey of 31,000 people across 31 countries, and that survey is more than two years old.
We went the other direction. At Hollywood Branded, using AI is now a required part of our applicant assessments, and I've been redesigning those assessments around it. That can sound like we made the test easier. We moved the hard part. In this article, I explain why we made AI mandatory in our hiring assessment and what we're actually testing for.
Quick answer: Hollywood Branded requires AI use in its hiring assessments because the job itself now involves AI. According to COO Ian Drummond, the goal is to test judgment: how well a candidate frames a task, questions the output, catches errors and owns the final result. Prompt tricks matter far less than the thinking around them.
Testing for a Job That Still Exists
An assessment is supposed to preview the work. If the work involves AI every day, an assessment that bans it is testing for a job that has quietly disappeared. Our team builds AI workflows across Microsoft 365, PandaDoc and Claude, for drafting, summarizing, organizing research and preparing documents. A new hire is going to use those tools in week one.
The same Microsoft and LinkedIn research found that 78% of AI users were already bringing their own AI tools to work. People are using it whether their employer has a plan or not. I'd rather see how a candidate uses AI in the open than pretend they won't use it once they're hired, and I'd like candidates to know exactly what they're walking into, too.
What Are We Actually Testing For?
Judgment. Specifically, the judgment involved in guiding a tool that is fast, confident and sometimes wrong. We want to see how a candidate sets up a task: what context they give, what they ask for and what they leave out. We want to see whether they read the output critically, check facts against a source, notice when something sounds right but isn't, and revise until the work meets the standard.
Most of all, we want to see ownership. The final product carries the candidate's name, the same way a client deliverable carries ours. "The AI wrote that" is not an answer we accept from the team, so it's not one we accept in the assessment.
Twenty-two years of grading essays taught me that the revision tells you more about a writer than the first draft does. AI makes first drafts cheap. The revision is where you find out who can think.
Why Prompt Tricks Don't Impress Us
There's a cottage industry of magic prompts promising perfect output if you phrase things just so. English teachers have seen this movie before, just with a different study guide. Some of it helps at the margins, but nothing in it replaces knowing what good looks like.
A candidate who writes an elaborate prompt and accepts whatever comes back is showing us one skill. A candidate who writes a plain request, spots that the output misread the brief, and fixes it is showing us the skill we hire for. In a pop culture agency, the details matter: the correct name of a show, the difference between a product placement and a licensing deal, what a partner has and hasn't approved. AI will happily blur those lines if nobody's watching.
Somebody has to be watching.
Where Does the Human Part of the Job Live?
AI fluency at an agency looks pretty ordinary up close. It's turning a long call into clear next steps with owners and dates. It's getting a first pass of research on a brand category so a strategist can spend the afternoon on the interesting questions. It's preparing a summary of a contract so the person reviewing it knows where to look first.
What AI can't do is the part clients actually hire us for. It doesn't know which partner needs a phone call instead of another email, when a creative idea fits a show and when it would feel forced, or whether a deal works for both sides. Relationships, negotiation and creative calls stay with people.
So the assessment asks a simple thing: can this person use the tool to clear the busywork, then bring real judgment to what's left? That's the hire.
What This Means for Brands Working With an Agency
If you're a brand, the people on your account are almost certainly using AI already. That can be very good news. It means faster research, faster first drafts and more time spent on strategy and relationships, which is where an agency earns its keep.
It's worth asking any agency partner how its team uses AI and where human review happens. Ask how it protects confidential information when using AI tools, and who signs off on the final work. A good partner will have clear answers, because it has thought about the risks as carefully as the shortcuts.
At Hollywood Branded, we want to be a modern, tech-enabled agency, and that starts with the people we hire. The tools will keep changing every few months, and we'll keep needing people who can tell a strong answer from a merely plausible one.
Start With One Assessment
If you hire people, you don't need to rebuild your whole process this quarter. Pick one assessment for one role, make AI part of it, and tell candidates up front exactly what's expected. Give everyone the same tools and the same instructions, so the only variable left is how each person thinks.
Then grade the judgment. You'll learn more about your candidates in an hour than a stack of perfectly formatted cover letters will ever tell you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Should companies allow AI in hiring assessments?
A. If the job involves using AI, allowing or requiring it in the assessment gives a more accurate preview of how a candidate will perform. The key is to set clear expectations, give every candidate the same tools and instructions, and evaluate how they guide, check and improve the AI's output.
Q. What AI skills should employers test for when hiring?
A. Employers should test judgment more than prompt-writing technique. That includes framing a task clearly, giving useful context, reading output critically, verifying facts against sources, catching errors and taking ownership of the final work product.
Q. Is it fair to require AI in a job application assessment?
A. It can be fair when the requirement is announced in advance and every candidate has equal access to the same tools and clear instructions. Fairness comes from evaluating every candidate on the same criteria, with a focus on reasoning and quality rather than familiarity with a particular tool.
Eager To Learn More?
Thinking about how AI is changing marketing work? Start with these.
- Why Answer Engine Optimization Is the New Frontier for Brands
- Why Does Creative Strategy Matter More Than Marketing Metrics?
- Why Your Agency Partner Choice Defines Your Success
Want to stay in the know with all things pop culture? Look no further than our Hot in Hollywood newsletter! Each week, we compile a list of the most talked-about moments in the entertainment industry, all for you to enjoy!

