Why Do Underdog Stories Sell So Well for Brands?

Quick Answer

 

Why do underdog stories sell so well for brands? Norway's 2026 World Cup run, the research on the underdog effect and why brands must show up early.

Why Do Underdog Stories Sell So Well for Brands?

Norway hadn't been to a World Cup in 28 years. Then they won all eight of their qualifiers, scored 37 goals and beat Italy twice, finishing the job with a 4-1 win at San Siro in November 2025. This summer, they knocked five-time champion Brazil out of the tournament. They weren't supposed to do any of that.

Now that the 2026 World Cup is a few months behind us, the commercial lessons are easier to see. As someone who played the game at a high level and still follows it closely, I think Norway's run is a near-perfect case study, both for the fans who fell for that team and for the brands that were already there when it happened. In this article, I break down why underdog stories sell so well, and what brands should do about it, from my seat as COO of Hollywood Branded.

Quick answer: Underdog stories sell because audiences identify with disadvantage and admire determination. Research published in the Journal of Consumer Research found that brands framed as underdogs with real passion increase purchase intent. The catch is timing: underdog moments rise fast, so brands need relationships and plans in place before the story breaks.


Twenty-Eight Years, Then Brazil

The on-field story is almost too neat. Norway qualified with an unbeaten, eight-win campaign in which Erling Haaland scored 16 goals, according to beIN Sports. At the tournament, they advanced out of their group, then beat Brazil 2-1 at MetLife Stadium on July 5, 2026, with Haaland scoring twice, as The Tribune reported.

The run ended in the quarterfinal on July 11, when Jude Bellingham scored twice to give England a 2-1 win in extra time. It was still Norway's first World Cup quarterfinal ever. For one summer, a team that had spent 28 years watching from home became everyone's second-favorite.

And Norway wasn't even the smallest underdog in the field. Curaçao, with a population of about 156,000, was recognized as the smallest nation by population ever to qualify for a World Cup. The 2026 tournament was full of these stories.


Why Do Audiences Root for Underdogs?

The instinct that makes a neutral fan adopt Norway for a month, scarf and all, also shows up in how people buy. In a study published in the Journal of Consumer Research, Neeru Paharia, Anat Keinan, Jill Avery and Juliet Schor found that consumers identify with brands they see as underdogs, partly because most people have felt disadvantaged at some point. According to the study's announcement, the strongest effect came from brand stories that combined two things: a disadvantaged position against a bigger rival, and real passion and determination to beat the odds. In one test, participants chose the underdog brand 71% of the time.

Both halves matter. Disadvantage alone is just a sad story and determination alone is just bragging, but put them together and people want to be part of it. Norway checked both boxes, and so do plenty of brands with garage origins and a real fight in them.


The Underdog Window Closes Fast

Here's the part brands miss. Norway beat Brazil on July 5 and was out of the tournament six days later. If your plan for riding an underdog story starts after the upset, you have less than a week to find a partner, get legal approval, produce creative and get it in front of people. In practice, you have no window at all.

The brands that benefit are the ones already in the room. Nike's "Rip The Script" World Cup campaign, released in early June, already featured Haaland, plus Channing Tatum dressed as his stunt double, as Man of Many described. Weeks later, Newsweek reported that Tatum showed up to Norway's group match against France in Foxborough dressed as Haaland. The campaign was in place before the story got big, so the story kept feeding it. Anyone who runs a fantasy EPL league knows the same lesson from the other side: by the time every manager is transferring in the hot player, his price has already gone up.


What Does This Mean for Brands Planning Around Big Moments?

The underdog story sells itself, if you show up before everyone else does. That makes it a planning problem first, and it's the reason Hollywood Branded built its pathway the way it did: Playbook → Radar → Unlock Access → Produce → Amplify → Grow. The Playbook decides which kinds of stories fit a brand. Radar, which tracks more than 6,000 opportunities, is how you spot the rising team, film, creator or event before the headlines do. Unlock Access is where relationships get built early enough to matter.

The Amplify step only works when there's something real to amplify: an actual partnership, an actual asset, an actual moment. You can plan for it in advance, but you can't fake it after the fact. Brands that try to bolt themselves onto an underdog story at the last minute usually look exactly like what they are.

There's also a lesson for challenger brands telling their own story. If you really are the smaller player, say so, and show the determination behind it. Audiences reward that combination, and it gives you a reason to partner with other underdogs who share it.


Find Your Next Norway Now

The next big cycle is already on the calendar, with LA28 on the horizon and a full slate of tentpole releases, tours and seasons in between. Somewhere in that schedule is a story nobody is paying attention to yet.

The next step is to list the events, releases and teams in your category for the next 18 months, flag the ones with a real underdog in them and start the relationship conversations now. That's how your brand is standing there when the upset happens.

New call-to-action


Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What is the underdog effect in marketing?

A. The underdog effect describes how consumers prefer brands that present themselves as disadvantaged but determined. Research by Paharia, Keinan, Avery and Schor in the Journal of Consumer Research found the strongest response when a brand story combined an external disadvantage with passion and determination to succeed.


Q. How far did Norway go in the 2026 World Cup?

A. Norway reached the quarterfinals of the 2026 World Cup, its first World Cup quarterfinal ever. After returning to the tournament for the first time since 1998, Norway beat Brazil 2-1 on July 5, 2026, before losing to England 2-1 in extra time on July 11.


Q. How can brands take advantage of underdog moments in sports?

A. Brands need to plan before the moment happens. Underdog runs often last only days, which is too short to start a partnership from scratch. Brands that track upcoming opportunities, build relationships early and have approved plans ready are the ones that benefit when an underdog story breaks.


Eager To Learn More?

More reads on sports moments and the brands that show up for them.

Want to stay in the know with all things pop culture? Look no further than our Hot in Hollywood newsletter! Each week, we compile a list of the most talked-about moments in the entertainment industry, all for you to enjoy!

New call-to-action

 

Table Of Contents

    WHAT'S HOT IN HOLLYWOOD

    Want to keep your pulse on what Hollywood has to offer? Sign up below to get on our HOT IN HOLLYWOOD partnership updates!