Tarte Cosmetics: A Rollercoaster Journey Through Influencer Marketing

Tarte's Influence in the Beauty World

The Rise of Tarte in the Influencer Space

Tarte Cosmetics was among the first beauty brands to truly leverage influencer marketing as a key strategy. Before influencer marketing became the norm, Tarte tapped into this space, identifying the power of beauty bloggers and social media influencers in creating genuine connections with their audiences. This approach allowed Tarte to showcase its products in a real-world setting, making them more relatable and desirable to potential consumers.

Photo taken from tarte.com

Influencer Trips: A Signature Move

One of the most notable aspects of Tarte’s influencer marketing strategy has been their lavish trips, often referred to as “Tarte Trips.” The brand regularly invites beauty influencers on all-expenses-paid vacations to exotic locations, creating massive buzz and generating viral content. These trips often involve luxury accommodations, themed activities, and endless product giveaways, all while showcasing Tarte's latest products.

For example, in 2018, Tarte flew a group of influencers to Bora Bora, a move that garnered millions of views across various social media platforms. The Bora Bora trip became one of the most talked-about campaigns in the beauty industry that year, with influencers sharing beautiful photos, makeup tutorials, and candid moments that made their followers feel like they were part of the experience. The concept also allows different influencers with similar followings so that this audience is heavily fed this luxurious content from multiple influencers in their feed. This strategy effectively positioned Tarte as a fun, adventurous, and aspirational brand, helping to increase product sales and brand loyalty.

Tarte brand trip to Bora Bora. Image courtesy of Maureen Kelly, founder and CEO. 

Building Community Through Influencer Relationships 

Beyond the trips, Tarte has consistently engaged with influencers on a personal level, often fostering genuine relationships. This approach has led to long-term collaborations with influencers who genuinely love and believe in the brand. Such relationships have contributed to Tarte's authenticity and relatability in the eyes of consumers, who trust their favorite influencers' recommendations.

the challenges and missteps in tarte's influencer strategy 

Despite its success, Tarte has also faced criticism and controversies, especially as the influencer marketing landscape has evolved and become more transparent. As a brand that is frequently in the spotlight, Tarte's actions are constantly scrutinized, leading to several instances where their marketing efforts have backfired or sparked debates.

The Foundation Shade Range Controversy

In 2018, Tarte faced significant backlash over the limited shade range of its highly anticipated Shape Tape Foundation. When the product was launched, many beauty influencers and consumers were disappointed by the lack of inclusivity, with only 15 shades available, and the majority catering to lighter skin tones. This misstep triggered conversations about the beauty industry's long-standing issues with diversity and inclusivity, and Tarte found itself at the center of that conversation.

Influencers, including Jackie Aina and Alissa Ashley, called out the brand for its lack of diversity, which resulted in a drop in consumer trust and loyalty. Tarte quickly responded to the criticism by promising to expand its shade range, but the damage had been done. This incident served as a reminder that in today's social media-driven world, consumers demand brands to be more inclusive and aware of the needs of all skin tones.

The Hermes Bracelet Scandal: Uneven Gifting Experiences 

More recently, Tarte found itself in hot water again with an influencer gifting scandal that brought attention to the perceived favoritism and discrepancies in their gifting practices. During a promotional campaign, Tarte sent out PR packages to various influencers. Some influencers received high-end Hermes bracelets, while others received less expensive items, sparking outrage and confusion among the influencer community.

This uneven treatment became a topic of discussion across social media, as many felt that Tarte was showing favoritism towards certain influencers. It raised questions about transparency and equity within influencer partnerships, with some influencers expressing disappointment and frustration over the perceived inequality. While gifting in different tiers is not uncommon in the influencer world, the stark contrast between Hermes bracelets and more modest gifts highlighted the potential pitfalls of such strategies, especially in an industry that values transparency and authenticity.

Unrealistic Expectations and Over-the-Top Extravagance  

Another criticism that Tarte has faced regarding its influencer trips is the perception of extravagance. While these trips have been effective in generating buzz, some critics argue that they set unrealistic expectations for beauty consumers and contribute to a culture of excess. In a time when consumers are becoming increasingly conscious of sustainability and the environment, the lavish nature of these trips has been called into question, leading some to wonder if Tarte's marketing budget could be used in a more impactful or ethical manner.

tarte's response and resilience   

Despite these controversies, Tarte has managed to maintain its position as a leading beauty brand, thanks in part to its ability to adapt and respond to feedback. After the foundation shade range backlash, for instance, Tarte took the criticism seriously and expanded its shade range to be more inclusive. This move demonstrated that the brand was willing to listen and learn, which helped regain some of the trust it had lost.

When faced with the Hermes bracelet scandal, Tarte was quick to address the situation and reaffirmed its commitment to building fair and meaningful relationships with influencers of all sizes. While some damage had been done, their openness to acknowledging the issue and working towards better practices in the future helped them retain credibility in the influencer community.

the positives: tarte's efforts to empower influencers and consumers 

It’s important to highlight that, despite these setbacks, Tarte has made several positive contributions to the influencer marketing space. Their willingness to partner with influencers of all sizes, from micro-influencers to mega-influencers, has provided opportunities for many up-and-coming creators to showcase their talents and grow their platforms. This inclusivity has allowed Tarte to connect with a diverse range of audiences and build a strong community around their brand.

Additionally, Tarte’s commitment to being a cruelty-free brand has resonated with ethically minded consumers and influencers, further cementing its position as a brand that cares about important social issues. Tarte has also been praised for its innovative products, with the Tarte Shape Tape Concealer becoming a cult favorite and a staple in many makeup bags worldwide, thanks in large part to influencer recommendations.

looking ahead: what can we learn from tastes journey?

Tarte’s journey in the influencer marketing space offers valuable lessons for other brands looking to make their mark. It’s a testament to the power of influencer marketing in building brand awareness and driving sales, but it also serves as a cautionary tale about the potential pitfalls of this strategy.

Key takeaways include the importance of being authentic, transparent, and inclusive, as well as the need to adapt to feedback and evolving consumer expectations. Tarte’s ability to bounce back from controversies demonstrates that brands can recover from missteps if they are willing to listen, learn, and make genuine efforts to improve.

tarte's lessons learned 

Tarte Cosmetics has undoubtedly experienced a rollercoaster ride in the influencer marketing space, with moments of brilliance and times of controversy. While they’ve faced challenges, Tarte remains a relevant and influential player in the beauty industry. Their willingness to experiment with bold strategies, coupled with a readiness to address and learn from mistakes, has allowed them to maintain their position as a beloved brand for many consumers and influencers alike.

In the ever-changing world of influencer marketing, Tarte’s story serves as both inspiration and a reminder that even established brands must continuously adapt and evolve to stay ahead of the game.

Want More? 

If you enjoyed this deep dive into Tarte's influencer marketing journey, we have plenty more insights waiting for you. Click below to explore more and keep your finger on the pulse of the industry!

• How One Brand Won Big On A Celebrity Influencer's Endorsement Mistake
• Transparency In Influencer Marketing
• Partnering Brands With Influencers
• Beauty Influencers Impact On Sales
• Hollywood Branded Best Of: Influencers

Still want to learn more? Check out our video exploring case studies of celebrity endorsement deals to learn all there is to know!